I Tossed My Old Pizza Recipe Out The Window – Or, How To Achieve Pizza Nirvana

This is it, my old trusty pizza dough recipe and method.  It is divorse and I get the oven in the settlement.  Goodbye, adieu, and I am never coming back.

Not you, new recipe. YOU are staying!

You see, I have a new love.  Actually, two of them, and they love me back, and we are very very happy (well, perhaps aside from the danger of increasing my derrierre).  Their names are Neapolitan pizza dough recipe and Zoe’s cast-iron skillet pizza baking method, and when they come together, there is a pizza nirvana the likes of which I’d not experienced since… I can’t remember.

I am very serious here.  Pizza is serious business.  I love pizza, and though it makes me gain weight in a frightful manner, I allow it to myself occasionally, as a treat.  And if I am going to use my dessert-allowance on pizza, it better be good.  In fact, it better be great – and this, this surpassed all my expectations.

I’ve made it twice now, to make sure it is no fluke, and it only got better the second time around.  Pinch myself – no, I am not dreaming.  I have indeed mastered pizza.  The sort of pizza that would make me not want to order it when out.  It’s a monumental event in my food-centric life.

And I am not talking about finding the perfect set of toppings here.  Every pizza aficionado will tell you that toppings do not a great pizza make – oh, they are necessary, but if the crust is cardboard, then no amount of parma ham, pepperoni, jalapenos, or whatever it is you love…

MUSHROOM, MUSHROOM! (To quote Weebl!)

… will make matters better.  You’d just end up picking the toppings off the disappointing crust.  So while the toppings are like the icing on the cake, the crust needs to be perfect for achieving pizza bliss.  This applies to any sort of pizza, from pan pizza to paper-thin variants, just that the parameters are different for each – but the point is still, if there are crust bits left on pizza plate after eating, it’s not right.

And having tried to make it this way is the first time me, T and guests have wolfed down the pizza, crust bits and all, and eyed each other’s plates hungrily despite there being a lot, and I mean – a lot! – of pizza.  And despite it having ended up accidentaly vegetarian (and we are all, the lot of us, carnivorous creatures).  It did not matter.  We were in out-of-this-world happy daze of pizza fulfillment.

I could go on and continue to wax poetic, but that’d be just mean.  Instead, I will tell you of the magic involved in this, so that you can experience it for yourself, for I am a strong believer that happiness multiplies when shared.  And I’m all for more (great) food to the people!

First of all, this dough takes a bit longer to make than most pizza dough recipes out there (including my old and now discarded one) – a total of about 3 hours (it’s worth every second).  Second, it has less ingredients (it does not need the added spices, garlic, and oil so often used to dress-up otherwise wrong recipes – like my old one!).  In fact, it’d suffer from having those in it, because – and here we get to the method! – they would all make it burn.

Why?  Because this method involves simulating a wood-fired brick oven in your own kitchen (safely, without breaking your oven’s thermostat or doing anything that goes against the building fire safety codes).  What does that mean?  It means high heat capacity and heat transfer cooking surface, and really high localized temperature.  You’ll need a cast iron skillet.  Nothing else in your kitchen can take this sort of thing (nor would it work).  But, before we get to the part about oven, you need to make the dough.

Dough recipe is adapted from my well-loved Italian cookbook “Savouring Italy” by Michele Scicolone, and it is, according to her, a recipe used in Naples, which is the Mecca of all pizza worshippers (or should be!).  I hadn’t used it originally because I love seasoning and all the other recipes advocated such, but having read up on the method (follows), I understand why the plain crust of flour, whater, yeast and salt is better.  And it is, oh yes, and how!

For 2 pizza crusts (feeds 2 hungry people) you need:

  • 300g bread flour
  • 180ml finger-warm water (+1 or 2 tablespoons if your air is dry or the flour is)
  • 2 teaspoons of fine salt (iodized table salt is fine here, though fine sea salt may taste even better)
  • 2 teaspoons of instant dry yeast (cake yeast would work fine too, I just had dry on hand and the recipe also specifies it)

Note:  I imagine this recipe will only be improved by making the dough with sourdough starter rather than just yeast.  I will experiment, adapt the recipe and post it when it is tested and ready for your consumption.  With photos.

Instructions are very simple (takes 3 hours to readiness to bake):

  • Put flour, salt and yeast in a large bowl and mix with a whisk to incorporate.
  • Add water and mix with a wooden spoon or a handheld mixer till all bits of flour are stuck to the shaggy ball of dough.  Cover with a damp kitchen towel and allow to stand for 10-15 minutes (you can take a shower, make coffee, hug boyfriend or whatever during this time).
  • Remove towel and if doing this by hand, turn dough onto a lightly floured surface to knead.  I use a mixer with dough hooks and just knead it in the bowl for about 10 minutes, until it is smooth, elastic and really friendly (read: doesn’t stick to bowl, hands or mixer).  The dough should be reasonably soft (lots of water) at this point.
  • Take a clean bowl (or wash the one you’d used and dry it), and lightly coat it with olive oil.  I mean lightly as in, drip a drop in and rub the inside of the bowl with oil using a paper towel, leaving just a thin film, not a hint of a puddle.  You just want the dough not to stick, but you also do not want to have oil on it, as that can lead to burning in high-heat baking.
  • Put the dough in the bowl, cover with a sheet of clingfilm (plastic wrap) and leave to rise for 1.5-2 hours until rather puffy.
  • Punch the dough down and knead a few times to smooth, then cut into half with a sharp knife or dough scraper, and shape into balls.  Rest those either back in the bowl, or on a sheet of baking paper, cover with clingfilm, and let rest for about an hour till they get fat and pillowy.
  • In the meantime, you want to prepare your toppings (whatever floats your pizza dreamboat!) and preheat the oven as high as it’ll go (takes about 30-60 minutes to get that hot with the cast iron pan inside – see method later).
  • When the oven is hot, and toppings are ready, put a sheet of baking paper onto a wooden board or a back of a cookie sheet to use as a peel, and dust it lightly with flour (you want the pizza to slide easily off it when it’s time!).
  • Take one of the balls of dough and, using gravity and your fingers, or, you know, your arm or tossing if you are that good at it (I’m not!), stretch it into a circle.  If it gets too springy, rest it on the floured parchment, and work on the other dough for a while.  Then rest that one down and go back to the first (gluten relaxes when not handled roughly).  Do not, I repeat, DO NOT use a rolling pin on it!!!  Apparently, that was my mistake, and it causes the crust to get more cardboardey!  We don’t want that!  Just keep working the dough and stretching it out, and it’ll come out just fine!
  • When you have 2 circles of dough flat on 2 boards (or one on the counter and one on a board), top them with whatever you want.  Now you are ready to bake.

Note:  I did not bother making a sauce – a drizzling of olive oil from a thin-spouted bottle did the trick here, but by all means, use pizza sauce, pesto, bechamel, whatever you like!  We used a large handful of gräddost (a semi-soft Swedish cheese reminiscent of fontina or gruyere, approximately 40-45% fat) with sliced fresh mushrooms on top and a dusting of dried oregano for one pizza, and sliced fresh fig, crumbled goat’s cheese and a little bit of hot dried red chili flakes for the other.  Or you could use the toppings from my old pizza post (but mind you, not the crust or method!).  The reason you want to do this while the dough rises the 2nd time is because you want your toppings close or at room temperature, so you want to take the chill off them for a few minutes, not use them straight from the fridge.   That, and it’s good to have everything prepared before you start assembling he pizza.

Baking method – the all-encompassingly important way to creating this food of the gods!

The method involves taking a cast-iron pan or skillet, enameled or not (plain seasoned would work fine too is my guess), popping a rack as high as it can go and still fit the pan below the top grill (broiler) of your oven, and preheating the pan in the oven set to the highest temperature it’ll go (mine says 275°C and that’s what I set it to).  Then, when you’ve got your pizza ready and oven is preheated or within 25°c of top temperature, pull the pan out of oven.  It’ll be bloody hot, so you want to use gloves and a non-wobbly wooden stand or large wooden board – I use a sturdy wooden step stool covered with a terry cotton rag.  (In fact, I’ve written in some detail regarding safely handling preheated cast iron for baking bread here.)

When this is all set up and you have your hot pan ready, you take your pizza (that is prepared and sitting on a wooden or metal peel-equivalent covered in parchment and flour so it’s slick) and slide it into the very hot, dry pan.  Best method I’ve found was suggested by Zoe too – having a boyfriend/friend/someone hold the wooden board with the pizza over the pan, while I grab the edge and carefully slide the pizza over into the pan.  Then, you pop the pan into the oven, turn on your top grill (broiler) + fan option if you have it, and watch.  This is not a walk-away for 15 minutes sort of baking, it’ll cook right in front of your eyes to done in less than 5 minutes if even that.  I tend to watch for first signs of blush on the crust, and then rotate the pan (so the side that faced outside is now inside) and let it get to perfect state of doneness.  Then I use a pair of steel tongs to grasp the pizza by the edge, and using a steel spatula drag it onto a plate held by a boyfriend/helpful other person.

There.  Put the plate away (it’s too hot to eat anyhow!) and repeat with second pizza.  I found I like to put the pan into the oven for about 1-2 minutes between the pizzas to preheat it before the second one, but I am not sure it’s strictly necessary.  Also, as fast as this cooks, by the time the 2nd pizza is done, the first one is just about ok temperature to not burn your mouth off – so take them both to the table, pour a glass of your favorite wine, and achieve pizza nirvana.

Cry, because most delivery and restaurant pizza will never measure up.  Then stop crying because you can repeat this incredible experience as often as you want (or as your mirror and size of your waist allow you, but that, my friends, is strictly between you, mirror and the jeans)!


12 thoughts on “I Tossed My Old Pizza Recipe Out The Window – Or, How To Achieve Pizza Nirvana

    1. Karen, don’t worry, it’s not as scary as it sounds at first, but you do have to be really careful when handling sizzle-hot cast iron! But if an admitted clutz like me can do it, so can you!

      And … SO worth the effort!

  1. Yay! I’m so glad you liked this method as much as I did. And yes, it will definitely work in plain (non-enameled) cast iron.

    I’m going to have to try that pizza dough method, too, maybe with a little whole wheat flour mixed in (just ‘cuz I like it like that).

    1. Thank you thank you thank you for introducing me to the method! I was already a cast-iron worshipper, but now I am eyeing a 17″ cast iron pan online… I also now have a boyfriend+herd of male friends who want pizza! The ravenous eyes while it was getting baked were fantastic!!!

      I suspect it’ll work fine with a little of whole wheat too – I sometimes do that myself. I may try a bit of it when I adapt this to sourdough starter instead of yeast as well (which ought to be even better, if that were possible!).

      Thank you again! … Must resist making pizza all the time!

    1. Oh, Ping, did you find a pan yet? I’ve been drooling over this huge flat-bottom one with 2 small handles on sides on amazon.co.uk, but I am not sure I can justify it to myself… yet.

      And you seriously need to make it! Anyone who loves pizza does!

  2. Greetings. This is my first time on your blog, but you have a terrific one. I am always on the look out for new blogs, new ideas. I especially appreciate all the details you do. Great photos makes it seem like anyone can replicate the recipe!

    I am asking, would you please consider posting a few of your favorite recipes on erecipecards.com

    It is a tool for bloggers to see and to be seen. Your posts would fit in perfectly.

    in addition, all photos, recipe titles as well as your blog name would link directly back to your blog. Thus giving you new attention and potentially new readers.

    Or, if you just want to take a look at a lot of fellow food bloggers all in one place. A great learning experience to get ideas about how to establish your own blogging voice!

    We have a very easy to follow step by step photo guide to help you get started…

    Please take a look. If you have any ideas or questions, please do not hesitate to write


  3. I just found your blog through YeastSpotting and am sooo happy that I did! I have just spent a lot of time looking at your recipes and they all look so good,but I think I’ll start with this one. I’m sure I’ll be throwing out my old pizza recipe too! Thanks for sharing.

    1. Hey and I am glad you did! Welcome!

      If you want to start with a pizza, I would happily recommend this method (which has advantage of being very quick), but please take a look at this one one as well – the pizza crust done in that method is not a spur-of-the-moment thing, but it turns out fantastic (and the dough can be stored – I’ve tested that for a week)!

  4. You put figs on your pizza, I want to snog you! Thanks for the recipe, your pizza is a much more beautiful shape than mine. p.s. I find fine semolina helps for a crusty base instead of flour when shaping/on the base and tray when baking.

    1. Hey, thank you for visiting my blog, and I’m sorry for the slow reply – we are relocating to another country right now, so it’s been insane here! Thank you for the tip about semolina, I really should try that – we are moving to Central Finland (that’s pretty far North even compared to Stockholm, and there may not be as much good takeout pizza around, so I’ll have opportunity and motive!). Also, yay, another figs-on-pizza lover! :) Are you a fan of goats’ cheese, too, by any chance?

      More people should!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s